I agree with pretty much all of this, of course the specifics need to actually get worked out. Doesn’t Google forms require an email to login? I don’t have much experience with mirror but if it’s more anonymous, then it is likely a better choice. Or they can post in the forum and follow a specific post template, though that might be a little much. I wouldn’t want to overwhelm the forum, but if we add a specific section for each: grants, bounties, and retroactive rewards, then have a template post pinned to the top, as well as the rubric, that might work. Obviously as far as the rubric goes, for retroactive rewards it wouldn’t need the “feasibility” section, so is there a third scoring criteria we can add so it isn’t just “impact” and “ROI”? For the other two, I believe the three categories mentioned work okay.