I’d recommend RPIPs. The argument of “it’s so simple it doesn’t need one” is matched up against “then the rpip will take 5 minutes to write”. Nice to have one place to look, a link to the forum, and the soft sections explaining purpose, eg. Also entirely dodges the judgement calls around whether a specific change needs an RPIP.
1 Like
Agree with Val. Should use RPIPs, even for this type of parameter change. Keep it all official.
Batch #8
0x08a79c8dd7a6d8d5d7810d1933f5713a8f31fb7fcb6b4632ef5b98af6decc151
Gas Price: 2.07 gwei
Transaction Fee: 0.0289 ETH
Total Initialized Vote Power: 83,245 (96.45%)
0.228 ETH collected from 41 POAPs
0.283 ETH spent to initialize 400 nodes
Batch #9
0x26c8185f1540860f95812e12b0c41d3e9a2866d81adccfce9fe5415e0668fdff
Gas Price: 2 gwei
Transaction Fee: 0.0281 ETH
Total Initialized Vote Power: 84,058 (97.4%)
0.240 ETH collected from 43 POAPs
0.311 ETH spent to initialize 450 nodes
Batch #10
0xb56793f7ccecc5acc4f0d63175c6693c38a5523f0c482ecdf63c0cb2e511131a
Gas Price: 1.97 gwei
Transaction Fee: 0.0277 ETH
Total Initialized Vote Power: 84,796 (98.25%)
0.240 ETH collected from 43 POAPs
0.339 ETH spent to initialize 500 nodes
Batch #11
0xd23ef9c2dbf65ad8f3413cd6233ec637095e67ab3fa5fd8918e211d3777a9ee0
Gas Price: 1.77 gwei
Transaction Fee: 0.025 ETH
Total Initialized Vote Power: 85,504 (99.04%)
0.240 ETH collected from 43 POAPs
0.364 ETH spent to initialize 550 nodes
Batch #12
0xd4984b3519605a97560019df1f75ffbee7d41a58edad13f52915d44e5be7266d
Gas Price: 1.75 gwei
Transaction Fee: 0.0248 ETH
Total Initialized Vote Power: 86,101 (99.73%)
0.240 ETH collected from 43 POAPs
0.389 ETH spent to initialize 600 nodes
Batch #13
0xf4f9969a959b1a77d98aa8fb7aa378f72dcd12ac38f5e65e2b39a4c42793de92
Gas Price: 1.67 gwei
Transaction Fee: 0.0114 ETH
Total Initialized Vote Power: 86,330 (100%)
0.24 ETH collected from 43 POAPs
0.40 ETH spent to initialize 624 nodes
1 Like
Yes should have an RPIP, particularly as normal technical level folks may have a tough time parsing the on-chain vote, depending on what the UI looks like.
Separately, if on-chain votes are occurring somewhat regularly, the RPIP field could get crowded pretty quickly. I think it already is. I wonder if it makes sense to just have a single living RPIP that on-chain votes (particularly parameter changes) get sequentially added to?
All 50 POAPs sold!
0.282 ETH went to me
0.018 ETH went to POAP
I sponsored the remaining 0.13 ETH to get to 100%
4 Likes