Round 19 - GMC Community Discussion of Submitted Applications

Bounties

:green_circle: RocketArb for closes

I wrote it so I unshockingly support it. People complain about this being missing slash ask for it to exist in discord. Thatā€™s pretty rare.

:green_circle: Rocket Pool Support Payments Dec 2024-May 2025

Huge differentiator for RP - yes.

:green_circle: :white_circle: STAR Initiative (rETH Incubator)

Support. I do have some tweaks Iā€™d suggest:

  • :star: Support minting and buying equally. Doesnā€™t really matter what the rETH demand looks like, and as good partners we shouldnā€™t be pushing folks to mint if thereā€™s a discount, eg.
  • Define tier 5 piecewise. Eg: 0.5% payout up to 2E (the first $1.6M), then 0.1% payout from there. I think thereā€™s value in both amount of demand and also in amount of treasuries that have rETH. If we can make diversifying into rETH (and/or going hard on rETH to make an ethos point) standard operating procedureā€¦ thatā€™s super valuable. Ie, Iā€™d be willing to pay more incentives for 40 $1M investments than for 1 $40M investment.
  • Pay out tier 5 with a stream (0xsplit, llamapay, etc). If the rETH is sold/burned, GMC can stop the stream.

:red_circle: Lottery for rETH holders

I donā€™t see any reason to believe this would generate significant demand. Pooltogether has a WETH pool making 8.3% that has attracted under 300 ETH. To put that in perspective, we have a rETH yield around 2.9%, so getting that to 8.3% would require ~2100 ETH per period (rETH_TVL_in_ETH*(apy/13) = 507630.63*((0.083-.029)/13)), which is over 100x the GMC budget per period. Maybe we do a bit better cuz itā€™s ETH instead of the POOL token, but it feels like weā€™re orders of magnitude away.

Pushing back on @peteris ā€“ itā€™s $1k to develop the infra, but the main cost is funding the lottery itself.

(update 12/26: my numbers above are to get all of rETH to 8.3% which isnā€™t fair. Itā€™s probably more fair to say something like ā€œhaving this pool attract 1% of rETH TVL would cost 21 ETH per period, which is approximately 110% of the full GMC budgetā€ or maybe ā€œthis demand multiplier might be around 15x, which is worse than we see in LPs as describe in Discordā€)

Retros

None

Grants

:red_circle: Rocket Pool Validator Monitoring Integration with ethseer.io

Itā€™s unclear to me whatā€™s being offered here. Is it just adding the RP label to their existing stuff? If so, it seems like beaconcha.in lite. See https://beaconcha.in/validator/6791 vs https://ethseer.io/validator/6791?network=mainnet. It sounds like maybe the intent is to allow grouping into validator or RP node, so maybe thatā€™s moderately interesting? $8k isnā€™t a lot, but Iā€™m currently not clear on a unique feature being added or a feature being refined to be better than otherwise available.

:red_circle: Rocketpool AI Assistant

Iā€™m very against AI for things where (a) errors matter a lot and (b) the consumer is not expert enough to check if the answer is good or not. Likeā€¦ what if the AI tells someone that the way to burn rETH is by transferring to the rETH contract or something? Big nope.

Also telegram isnā€™t used by the community.

3 Likes