Round 19 - GMC Community Discussion of Submitted Applications

Bounties

:green_circle: RocketArb for closes

I wrote it so I unshockingly support it. People complain about this being missing slash ask for it to exist in discord. That’s pretty rare.

:green_circle: Rocket Pool Support Payments Dec 2024-May 2025

Huge differentiator for RP - yes.

:green_circle: :white_circle: STAR Initiative (rETH Incubator)

Support. I do have some tweaks I’d suggest:

  • :star: Support minting and buying equally. Doesn’t really matter what the rETH demand looks like, and as good partners we shouldn’t be pushing folks to mint if there’s a discount, eg.
  • Define tier 5 piecewise. Eg: 0.5% payout up to 2E (the first $1.6M), then 0.1% payout from there. I think there’s value in both amount of demand and also in amount of treasuries that have rETH. If we can make diversifying into rETH (and/or going hard on rETH to make an ethos point) standard operating procedure… that’s super valuable. Ie, I’d be willing to pay more incentives for 40 $1M investments than for 1 $40M investment.
  • Pay out tier 5 with a stream (0xsplit, llamapay, etc). If the rETH is sold/burned, GMC can stop the stream.

:red_circle: Lottery for rETH holders

I don’t see any reason to believe this would generate significant demand. Pooltogether has a WETH pool making 8.3% that has attracted under 300 ETH. To put that in perspective, we have a rETH yield around 2.9%, so getting that to 8.3% would require ~2100 ETH per period (rETH_TVL_in_ETH*(apy/13) = 507630.63*((0.083-.029)/13)), which is over 100x the GMC budget per period. Maybe we do a bit better cuz it’s ETH instead of the POOL token, but it feels like we’re orders of magnitude away.

Pushing back on @peteris – it’s $1k to develop the infra, but the main cost is funding the lottery itself.

(update 12/26: my numbers above are to get all of rETH to 8.3% which isn’t fair. It’s probably more fair to say something like ā€œhaving this pool attract 1% of rETH TVL would cost 21 ETH per period, which is approximately 110% of the full GMC budgetā€ or maybe ā€œthis demand multiplier might be around 15x, which is worse than we see in LPs as describe in Discordā€)

Retros

None

Grants

:red_circle: Rocket Pool Validator Monitoring Integration with ethseer.io

It’s unclear to me what’s being offered here. Is it just adding the RP label to their existing stuff? If so, it seems like beaconcha.in lite. See https://beaconcha.in/validator/6791 vs https://ethseer.io/validator/6791?network=mainnet. It sounds like maybe the intent is to allow grouping into validator or RP node, so maybe that’s moderately interesting? $8k isn’t a lot, but I’m currently not clear on a unique feature being added or a feature being refined to be better than otherwise available.

:red_circle: Rocketpool AI Assistant

I’m very against AI for things where (a) errors matter a lot and (b) the consumer is not expert enough to check if the answer is good or not. Like… what if the AI tells someone that the way to burn rETH is by transferring to the rETH contract or something? Big nope.

Also telegram isn’t used by the community.

3 Likes